Monday, June 25, 2018

To be or not to be: Does taking your job personally lead to a career success?

Image result for workaholic
https://www.hypnosisdownloads.com/job-skills/workaholic


Let me be clear from the beginning – this post does not contain a definite respond to the question in its title. And neither is helpful any search in 'career advice/inspiration/I’ll-tell-you-how-to-live-your-life’ literature. There is a more or less equal number of articles providing practical ways of “how to stop taking your job personally” and explaining ”why ‘don’t take it personally’ is terrible work advice”. One side references all the burn-out and over-stressed consequences, together with inability to separate your work-self from your-self. The other side responds with million examples of successful people who stayed focused, creative and full of ideas because they were personally and emotionally invested in their work.
Indeed, the more I think of it, the more paradoxical it sounds. It is quite difficult to imagine how someone can quickly and successfully progress in a career without being highly motivated to do his/her job, looking for more tasks than required, or spending more time than required trying to come up with innovative and creative solutions. Does a worker who shuts his/her computer down exactly at 5 pm and does not even think about his/her work until the next day 9 am (hello, the perfect ‘work-life’ balance!) get a significant career success?
On the other hand, ‘my job is my life’ actually works well only in the circumstances of the private businesses or small start-ups with a high degree of flexibility and freedom where the aforementioned innovative and creative solutions are welcomed. It does not work so perfectly when a worker is a small pawn in the company with many more managers/bosses above him/her who do not share his/her creative or innovative views and who prefer him/her to simply follow the long-established rules and do what he/she is asked to do. It does not work so well in - let’s be honest – most of public companies/organisations where a ‘personally invested’ worker gets frustrated and tired of banging his/her head against a brick wall and yields to ‘it’s just a job that brings me money and social security’ mantra.      
Among many articles and books advising either one or another and not solving the paradox, I have found only one that actually seemed to come up with a compromise. The author points out that the key to career success is not how personally invested a worker is in his/her job: it is worker’s self-determination. It means that regardless if what job position it is and what type of company, a worker him/herself decides what to take from it and where to go with what he/she takes:
Career self-determination doesn't require you to start your own business. My friend Mike has been insanely successful in his career working for well-known employers. What makes Mike successful is that he decides what he wants to do next rather than letting the job ads or inertia decide for him. When one job has given Mike all it's got to give, he moves on. He doesn't really care what his boss thinks about his performance. He cares what impact he's making at work -- impact that he can talk about later, with other employers, when it's time to move on! […]
Mike is self-employed in his own mind, although he works for other people. He loves his career, has plenty of time off, gets paid very well and best of all, is healthy and happy. Mike is not a suck-up or someone who needs to get external approval to feel good about himself. He simply knows what kinds of Business Pain he solves for employers, and that knowledge makes him very valuable as well as content in his own skin.
I guess the solution proposed here is this: in order to succeed in career, it is not necessary to take one’s own job personally, but it is essential to be personally and emotionally invested in one’s own career plan and vision. In short, the personal career plan is the determining factor of deciding where and how much to invest personally in the current job tasks. And if one or another job task doesn’t contribute to the career plan, why take it personally?
Useful (and not so much) resources: Duncan Coombe Don’t Take It Personally” Is Terrible Work Advice, Harvard Business Review; How Liking Your Job Will Help You Succeed, University of Southern California, Online Master of Science in Applied Psychology; John Rampton 15 Behaviors Blocking Your Success; John Fawkes 10 things you must stop doing if you want to be successful, Medium; Becky Hagle 5 Things That Happen When You Take Your Job Too Seriously, Odyssey; Liz Ryan Hard Work Won't Make You Successful -- But Doing This Will, Forbes.

No comments:

Post a Comment